Dining Room Design and Decor

November 27, 2024

Designing the Perfect Dining Room: Timeless Function and Form

When it comes to designing and building the perfect dining room, the goal is to create a space that serves as the heart of a home—where functionality meets timeless elegance. For general contractors working with historically motivated architecture, especially with inspirations from renowned architects like Patrick Ahearn, the dining room must seamlessly blend classical design elements with modern conveniences.
Here’s a guide to designing and building a dining room that embodies historical charm while accommodating contemporary living.


1. Design for the Architecture

A well-designed dining room is not just a stand-alone space; it should harmonize with the home’s overall architectural style. For homes inspired by Colonial Revival or Federal design, consider:

Greek Revival Harbor House, Photo credits: Greg Premru

Symmetry and Proportion: Dining rooms in historical homes are often defined by balanced layouts. Center the table under a statement chandelier, framed by evenly spaced windows or doors.

Materials and Millwork: Incorporate historically accurate wainscoting, crown moldings, and baseboards to add character and depth. High-quality hardwood floors, such as wide-plank oak, are a timeless choice.

Color Palette: Stick to classic tones like soft whites, creams, or historical hues.


2. Prioritize Functionality

The dining room should accommodate both intimate family dinners and grand holiday feasts. A contractor’s expertise ensures the space is both beautiful and functional.

Urban Island Village Compound

Ample Space for Movement: Ensure at least 3 feet of clearance around the dining table for chairs to be pulled out comfortably. For larger gatherings, plan for expandable table options.

Built-In Features: Consider adding a custom buffet or cabinetry to store china, linens, and glassware. Integrating these features into the walls can save space while maintaining a historical feel.

Lighting: Layer lighting with a central chandelier and wall sconces to create ambiance. Ensure dimmer switches are installed for versatility.


3. Windows, Doors, and Views

Dining rooms should connect to the surrounding spaces and nature seamlessly, especially in homes on Martha’s Vineyard.

French Doors or Oversized Windows: Allow natural light to flood the room while providing views of the property’s landscaping. Patrick Ahearn’s designs often emphasize this indoor-outdoor relationship.

Transom Windows: A classic architectural detail that enhances historical accuracy while improving natural light flow.


4. Furnish with Intent

The right furnishings amplify the architectural details while keeping the dining room practical and inviting.

Morse Street Compound, Photo Credits: Greg Premru

Table and Chairs: Choose a timeless dining table—like a mahogany trestle or pedestal table—that reflects the home’s era. Pair with upholstered or ladder-back chairs to complete the look.

Rug Selection: A natural fiber or Oriental-style rug can ground the room while adding texture and warmth. Be sure to size it appropriately so chairs remain on the rug even when pulled out.

Artwork and Décor: Add curated pieces like vintage prints, a large mirror, or subtle seasonal décor to enhance the historical ambiance without overwhelming the space.

4. Seamlessly Integrate Modern Amenities

While staying true to historical design, don’t overlook modern amenities that improve convenience.

Faulkner Drive, Photo Credits : Greg Premru

Climate Control: Radiant floor heating or discreet HVAC systems maintain comfort without detracting from the room’s aesthetics.

Smart Technology: Incorporate hidden speakers or smart lighting systems that can be controlled remotely to suit various occasions.

Electrical and Outlets: Plan strategically placed outlets to accommodate seasonal décor, such as Thanksgiving centerpieces or holiday string lights.


6. Build with Precision

As general contractors specializing in historically motivated homes, craftsmanship is key. Collaborating with architects like Patrick Ahearn, we ensure every detail—from the framing to the finishing touches—aligns with the home’s narrative.

Herring Creek Farmhouse

Attention to Detail: From the hand-carved millwork to the precision of the plaster molding, every element should reflect historical accuracy.

Quality Materials: Use premium materials like solid wood, natural stone, and traditional finishes to enhance durability and authenticity.

Craftsmanship Partners: Partner with artisans and vendors experienced in recreating historically accurate components, from lighting fixtures to hardware.


A dining room isn’t just a place to share meals; it’s a space where stories are told, traditions are celebrated, and memories are made. For historically motivated architecture, the perfect dining room strikes a balance between form and function, combining period-appropriate details with modern convenience.
As builders, our role is to bring these spaces to life with precision, ensuring they honor the past while serving the present. Whether you’re renovating a Federal-style home in Edgartown or building a Colonial Revival on the outskirts of Katama, the perfect dining room is always within reach.
Ready to create your ideal dining space? Let’s build something timeless together.